Choosing a new roof is a significant investment. This detailed review compares Malarkey's Highlander and Highlander AR asphalt shingles, helping you decide which best suits your needs and budget. Both are positioned as premium, yet affordable, options offering superior durability and environmental benefits compared to standard asphalt shingles.
Highlander vs. Highlander AR: A Detailed Comparison
Both Highlander shingle types utilize Malarkey's NEX® polymer-modified asphalt (a strong, flexible material enhancing tear resistance), but the Highlander AR adds crucial algae resistance. Let's examine their key differences:
| Feature | Highlander | Highlander AR |
|---|---|---|
| Algae Resistance | No | Yes (backed by a 10-year warranty) |
| Wind Resistance | Up to 110 mph | Up to 130 mph |
| NEX® Technology | Incorporated for enhanced strength | Incorporated for enhanced strength |
| Warranty | Lifetime limited (see manufacturer details) | Lifetime limited (see manufacturer details) |
| Recycled Content | Contains recycled rubber and plastic | Contains recycled rubber and plastic |
| 3M™ Smog-Reducing Granules | No | Yes |
| Granule Retention | High | Higher (up to 65% improvement claimed) |
| Tear Strength | High | Higher (up to 10% improvement claimed) |
In-Depth Analysis: Highlander and Highlander AR
Highlander: This shingle offers excellent durability and wind resistance for its price point. The NEX® technology contributes to superior tear strength and granule retention, promising a long-lasting roof. However, it lacks algae resistance, potentially leading to discoloration and reduced lifespan in humid climates.
Highlander AR: Building upon the Highlander's strengths, the AR model adds algae resistance, crucial in regions prone to algae growth. This feature, backed by a 10-year warranty, extends the roof's aesthetic appeal and lifespan. The enhanced granule retention and tear strength further bolster its long-term performance. The inclusion of 3M™ Smog-Reducing Granules offers an additional environmental benefit.
Addressing Uncertainties
While Malarkey provides performance data, some information requires further clarification. The long-term performance of NEX® technology needs more independent verification. A detailed comparison of warranty conditions across both shingle types and those of competitors is also necessary for a fully informed decision. Finally, precise pricing information varies by location and installer, requiring multiple quotes for accurate cost assessment.
Installation and Maintenance
Proper installation is paramount for warranty validity and long-term performance. Always employ a qualified and experienced roofing professional familiar with Malarkey products. Regular roof inspections (annually recommended) help detect and address potential problems early.
Cost Considerations
Both Highlander shingles are positioned as premium, yet affordable, alternatives. However, the Highlander AR, with its additional features, commands a higher price. Obtain multiple quotes from reputable contractors to compare costs accurately. Remember that long-term savings from increased durability and extended lifespan can offset the higher initial investment.
Risk Assessment
While both shingles are designed for durability, potential risks exist. The likelihood of each issue is low with proper installation and maintenance but should still be considered:
| Feature | Likelihood of Problem | Potential Impact | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| NEX® Technology Failure | Low | Reduced shingle lifespan or performance | Proper installation; choose a reputable installer. |
| Granule Loss | Low | Minor aesthetic issues; potentially reduced performance | Regular inspections; consider climate factors. |
| Nail Placement Issues | Low | Roof leaks; warranty may be voided | Choose a highly-rated installer with proper training. |
| Algae Growth (Highlander) | Moderate (humid climates) | Discoloration; reduced aesthetic appeal | Consider Highlander AR in humid environments. |
Regulatory Considerations
Ensure both shingle types comply with all local building codes and energy efficiency standards. The Solar Reflectance Index (SRI) is a critical factor, affecting energy efficiency and potentially influencing costs or incentives. Consult your local building authority to verify compliance.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Shingle
Both Malarkey Highlander shingles offer significant upgrades over standard asphalt shingles. The Highlander AR is the superior choice in humid climates due to its algae resistance. For drier climates, the standard Highlander offers excellent value and durability. In either case, prioritize proper installation by a certified professional to maximize longevity and warranty coverage. Remember that a well-installed roof is a far more significant investment than the initial cost of the shingles themselves.